Candy's Pizza

If you find yourself in Montague, New Jersey, craving a truly exceptional pizza experience, Candy's Pizza is a must-visit destination. Specializing in classic American-style pizza, this local gem offers a menu centered around crowd-pleasers like Cheese Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Sicilian Pizza, and fresh House Salads—each prepared with a love for simplicity and flavor that shines through every bite.

What sets Candy’s apart is its mastery of the thin and crispy crust, a detail repeatedly praised by enthusiastic diners. One customer affectionately called it “one of the best I've ever had in NJ,” capturing the delight of a perfectly balanced crust that holds just the right amount of crunch while supporting rich, gooey cheese and robust sauce. If your palate craves something heartier, their Sicilian Pizza is a fan favorite—infamous for its thick, airy base and loaded with cheesy, saucy goodness that envelops you in a warm, comforting embrace.

The dining atmosphere inside Candy’s Pizza strikes a welcoming balance between homey and spacious. Although from the outside the building may appear modest, inside is a pleasantly roomy setting that invites families and groups to linger over meals. The friendly staff add a personal touch, often mentioned by guests who appreciate more than just the food but also the warm, genuine service they receive.

Regulars and visitors alike highlight the restaurant’s consistency in delivering fresh ingredients and satisfying flavors. Whether you’re stopping by on a road trip to nearby Milford, PA, or are taking on a local culinary challenge to explore New Jersey’s diverse eateries, Candy’s Pizza offers a memorable slice of Montague hospitality and craftsmanship. It’s not just a meal—it’s a warm, savory experience that invites you to savor the simple joys of expertly made pizza.

For those passionate about authentic pizza made with care, Candy’s Pizza is an inviting spot where crust crackles, cheese melts perfectly, and the buzz of satisfied conversations underscores every visit. When you want both top-notch flavor and a friendly vibe in the northernmost tip of the Garden State, Candy’s Pizza truly has your cravings covered.

Contact them at +1 973-293-8441 or visit at 452 US-206, Montague, NJ 07827 to treat yourself to a pizza experience that’s as memorable as it is delicious.